Friday, March 20, 2015

Video Games, Ethics, and the Internet: Library's Role in Access to Information

Libraries are in a difficult ethical position when it comes to providing access to information (intellectual freedom) and resources to its users. Video games are part of an ongoing discussion that comes up frequently, usually in the aftermath of violent and horrific acts when they involve young people. It is easy to point the finger at video games but it is hard to draw conclusive evidence that directly links violent video games to violent behavior.1 One way that society has tried to restrict the flow of violent video games to users they deem not suitable for the content is through the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB). Like the Motion Picture Association of America’s rating system for films, the ESRB rates content found in video games. Also like the MPAA, the ESRB was created with the same intentions. To establish a rating system so that parents can make informed choices as to what their children can play (ESRB.org, 2015). The ESRB ratings can be found here.

 The ESRB rating for Minecraft, taken from their website, is as follows:
This is puzzle-adventure game in which players mine pixilated landscapes to harvest stylized cube-like materials. From a first-person perspective, players traverse an “open-world” environment, avoid hazards, build new structures, and craft weapons (e.g., swords, axes, and bows) to occasionally defend against monsters (e.g., zombies, wolves, and skeletons). Though not encouraged, players can engage in violent acts such as lighting animals on fire and harming animals with weapons. Mild explosions are occasionally heard as players use dynamite to fend off creatures and mine the environment. (ESRB Website, 2015).
The ESRB rates the content in the video game but they are unable to rate the interactions that occur online. For this reason, if there is an online component to the game that aspect is not rated by the ESRB. Often this is displayed as “Online Interactions Not Rated By The ESRB.” This is intended to cover a wide range of online content like chat (text, audio, and video) and user-generated content.

A game rated M for Mature (ages 17 and up) can easily be dismissed as graphic or violent in nature compared to a game rated E for Everyone. However, Gadd and Kavanaugh (2009) argue that these games are often the best in terms of graphic, sound and gameplay quality and the M rating means the game often deals with death, deception, heroism and sacrifice. If you add events like sex, love, and loss in a video game you often end up with a very emotional experience for the user. This does not mean that violent and vulgar video games automatically translate into one that is deep and engaging, but it is hard to connect with your audience without drawing on powerful human emotions such as the ones listed above.

I do not agree that libraries should be the enforcers of these ratings (although rating movies, music, and video games can have benefits). As stated in the American Library Association’s Code of Ethics, “We uphold the principles of intellectual freedom and resist all efforts to censor library resources… [w]e protect each library user's right to privacy and confidentiality with respect to information sought or received and resources consulted, borrowed, acquired or transmitted” (ALA, 2008). These are of particular importance for why libraries should not be the gatekeeper to information. We should not be the control mechanism against users accessing information or resources.

To make this point, Section 5 of the Library Bill of Rights states “A person’s right to use a library should not be denied or abridged because of origin, age, background, or views” (ALA, 2015). From the wording of this statement it could be argued that this is aimed at the physical building that makes up the library and not the collection itself, but I would argue it extends far beyond the building. Libraries are no longer simply a brick and mortar structure to warehouse information.

This issue is addressed in the “Access for children and young adults to nonprint materials: an interpretation of the Library Bill of Rights” on the ALA website, which argues that librarians cannot act as in loco parentis but do support and acknowledge the rights of parents/guardians to guide their own children’s access to resources (ALA, 2004). The ALA also states, “When a work is expurgated, under the assumption that certain portions of that work would be harmful to minors, the situation is no less serious” (ALA, 1990). We are evolving into something far more organic and community-based and I think this statement should encompass everything that libraries stand for.

I would also like to argue that access to the internet is an important issue facing libraries. Some libraries use site blocking software to limit the use of certain websites. The problem with doing this however, is that by limiting users access to certain sites we are limiting what information is being consumed. Libraries need to walk a very fine line between limiting access to potentially harmful information found online and restricting access altogether. The very nature of the internet as a virtual, anonymous and largely unregulated space is proving to be a very difficult situation for libraries and legislation such as the Children’s Information Protection Act (CIPA) further add to the ethical situation that libraries face.
iNet Protector 4 - Screenshot 7
My city’s public library has an extensive policy for use of public computers and specifically draw attention to minors. The Ottawa Public Library says, “As with other library materials, parents and guardians must assume responsibility for deciding which resources are appropriate for the children in their care. To address the issue of access, parents or guardians have the choice of selecting filtered or unfiltered Internet access in all locations. Access for children is defaulted at filtered unless unfiltered access is requested in person by a parent/guardian. Filtering technology is imperfect, however and parents and legal guardians are responsible for their children’s use of the Internet” (Ottawa Public Library website, n.d.). In the United States courts have ruled that parents have the right to only limit access to library materials for their children and should not extend their own limits to other people’s children (Hansen, n.d.). It is extremely important for libraries to create strong policies on collection development and internet use for the institution.

At its core libraries offer users an uncensored experience to facilitate deep learning. It is built into the ALA’s Code of Ethics as well as their Bill of Rights. As a worldwide leader, a respected library presence, and an authority in libraries, it is easy to see that these codes and bills are important and of core value to the library institution. However, should libraries enforce rules to protect certain library users (children) or should we extend these values across all age groups? In the end it is ultimately up to parents but opening communication with them and providing education in responsible internet use and new emerging technologies such as video games is key in constructing a strong policy that both protects but does not restrict users access to information.

Further reading:

The topic of censorship in libraries is so large that addressing all of the issues surrounding them in a single blog post was difficult. I would like to include a further reading list as I think the following are extremely important for this topic.

American Library Association. (1990). Labels and rating systems: an interpretation of the Library Bill of Rights. Retrieved from http://www.ala.org/Template.cfm?Section=interpretations&Template=/ContentManagement/ContentDisplay.cfm&ContentID=8657 

Family Entertainment Protection Act of 2005, S. 2126, 109th Cong. (2005). Fisher, Ken. (2005). Thompson calls FEPA unconstitutional. Ars technica Retrieved from http://arstechnica.com/uncategorized/2005/12/5740-2/

Resources:

American Library Association. (2004). Access for children and young adults to nonprint materials: an interpretation of the Library Bill of Rights. Retrieved from http://www.ala.org/Template.cfm?Section=interpretations&Template=/ContentManagement/ContentDisplay.cfm&ContentID=31870

American Library Association. (2008). Code of ethics of the American Library Association. Retrieved from http://www.ala.org/ala/issuesadvocacy/proethics/codeofethics/codeethics.cfm 

American Library Association. (1990). Expurgation of library materials: an interpretation of the Library Bill of Rights. Retrieved from http://www.ala.org/Template.cfm?Section=interpretations&Template=/ContentManagement/ContentDisplay.cfm&ContentID=8540 

Gadd, K., and Kavanaugh, T., (2009). Violence, addiction, and M-rated games. YA Hotline, 86, Retrieved from https://ojs.library.dal.ca/YAHS/article/view/170

Hansen, Debbie. [n.d.]. Module 9 Lecture 1: Intellectual Freedom and American Law [PDF document]. Retrieved from https://sjsu.instructure.com

Footnotes:

1. Although this is an important topic, it is beyond the scope of this blog post and is it is not of particular significance for the purpose of this blog post to pursue further.

Friday, March 6, 2015

Information Seeking Behavior, User Experience, and Community Member Interview for Minecraft

The internet has changed the way users seek and consume information. Identifying how users are doing this is the key to providing better user experience for library patrons. I had the opportunity to interview a member of my information community and an avid gamer/ Minecraft enthusiast.

When interviewing an information seeking user from my community one thing was readily apparent. Their information seeking behavior was largely taking place online through various user-generated channels like YouTube and Reddit. Typically Minecraft users are playing the game when they encounter a problem that requires them to seek information. Often these are problems that are encountered by other users as well. The very nature of building and constructing in Minecraft translates well to video services like YouTube.

There has been an increasing shift in information consumption for gaming communities. Let’s Play videos are of particular value to gamers according to my interview source. This type of video is recorded by the author (the gamer) and showcases them playing through a particular game. Let’s Play videos are becoming more and more popular as the technology becomes more affordable since people can now produce video more easily. These are valuable because they allow the user to witness gaming experience through an experienced gamer. In Minecraft, Yogscast and Achievement Hunter are popular examples that my interviewee identified. Often these videos are mixed with humorous and entertaining commentary.

Team Yogscast, an internet series dedicated mainly to creating Minecraft content

This gave me valuable insight into how users view the credibility and authority of the online content they are accessing. Typically, credibility can be assessed using things like frequency of publication (how often is new content being produced?), view count (how many times was this video viewed?) or number of likes the video has received (popularity according to the audience).

It was interesting to learn that my user did not put as much value in the comments section of videos. This is because the frequency of coming across a troll is quite high. A troll, according to Burnett (2000), is a user who posts a comment that is typically considered unpopular or untrue to create a ruse within other users or the community. In certain online communities comments are ranked higher on the comment board due to the number of responses, making comments from trolls the top comments.

I was also interested to learn that my interviewee was a content producer as well. Although they did not produce content frequently, they did when they thought something would be of value to the community. Flanagin, Hocevar & Samahito (2014) argued that the sense of community itself acts as an agent of authority for users. They state, “[W]hen people define themselves based upon a shared social group or category, they become ‘depersonalized’, perceiving increased instagroup similarities and acting based upon a shared identity and conception of self” (Flanagin, A.J., et al., p. 687).When people identify themselves with the community, they feel what they value will also be valued by other members of the community.

When asked about the role that libraries could play in the information seeking behavior of gaming users the interviewee was unsure. We spoke briefly about some books that were being produced about Minecraft gameplay (one example found here), but there was a concern about how up to date this information would be. Video games often receive regularly scheduled updates called patches, which often involve new content or changes to the way old content works (as seen in this infographic about the evolution of Minecraft). I think this is important to address. The landscape of gaming is changing. Video games are no longer static. As mentioned in the documentary Minecraft: A Story of Mojang, once a game is created today you can expect developers to patch, fix, and update content regularly, which often changes the entire game completely. Minecraft is even more complex because users can also modify (mod) the game (meaning create their own content for the game). A popular mod for Minecraft was called Technic. Technic was designed by users which allows them to create complex machinery in game that does not come with the base Minecraft experience. Users can download and play these mods, switch to new mods and revert to the original Minecraft game so quickly that published books cannot keep up with the evolution of the game. Web 2.0 allows for instant publication of materials within seconds of changes going live.

When asked what role the library could play in fostering a gaming community there was a very positive reaction. My interviewee thought the idea of bringing gaming to the library was an interesting idea. The collaborative potential of having people in the same room sharing ideas in person was something that interested them. The idea of the library as a space for collaboration is a key area worth exploring. Libraries need to evolve to stay relevant. In Aaron Schmidt’s guest lecture for week 7, he argues that by copying emerging trends libraries will always be one step behind, never ahead. By embracing new ways of thinking, libraries can evolve to meet the growing needs of its users and they can do this by identifying and learning who its users are. Instead of fighting change, libraries must embrace it. Schmidt (2015) argues that instead of shouting at its users, libraries must instead listen. This is the foundation to providing a good user experience.

Overall, my interview with my community member confirmed the foundational research that I have already conducted. The information seeking behavior of the Minecraft community is built largely upon Web 2.0’s connectivity and the ease and quickness to produce content. When users are the experts and the information they are seeking is so quickly changing, the content created is invaluable.

References:

Burnett, G. (2000). Information exchange in virtual communities: A typology. Information Research: An International Electronic Journal, 5, 82. Retrieved from http://www.informationr.net/ir/5-4/paper82.html

Flanagin, A. J., Hocevar, K. P., & Samahito, S. N. (2014). Connecting with the user-generated web: How group identification impacts online information sharing and evaluation. Information, Communication & Society, 17(6), 683-694. doi:10.1080/1369118X.2013.808361

Let’s Play (Video gaming). (n.d.). Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/

Levering, P. (Producer), & Owens, P. (Director). (2012). Minecraft: the story of Mojang [motion picture]. USA: 2 Player Productions.

Schmidt, Aaron. [n.d.]. Aaron Schmidt User Experience Lecture [PDF document]. Retrieved from https://sjsu.instructure.com

Friday, February 20, 2015

Information Seeking Theories including a Community Member Interview

Gaming communities are becoming interesting areas of study for libraries and information specialists. Not only are they an enjoyable pastime but they are becoming popular tools for teaching, collaborating and communicating. My research paper will focus on three theories that best describe and generalize the information seeking behaviours of gaming communities today. These three theories mesh well together and synergize into a single coherent idea about information and its use in gaming communities. The three theories are:

  1. The design of browsing and berrypicking techniques for the online search interface by Bates (1989).
  2. Everyday life information seeking by Savolainen (2009).
  3. Information exchange in virtual communities: A typology by Burnett (2000).

Using these three theories I will examine gaming communities’ search behaviour, how users rate material and how they identify useful and relevant information. Gaming is an interactive practice. Whether you play alone (also known as solo) or if you play within a larger community (multiplayer) you are interacting with either an artificial environment or other players. It is these interactions that make gaming an interesting community for information professionals to study. In a very general overview the theories say the following: Bates (1989) argues that the research process is not linear but in fact is an evolving process from beginning to end. It requires that information returned through queries is read and comprehended. This leads the user to modify the query to include additional information to refine their search and locate additional information. Savolainen (2009) argues that everyday life information seeking is extremely important to users today. People join communities in the hope that they will come across useful information just from being an active member of the community. Burnett (2000) deals directly with the important aspects of information communities in virtual space. Each user has specific roles and ways that they acquire information within these virtual spaces.

The Interview:

I recently had the chance to interview a history professor who uses gaming as a tool for their courses at the post-secondary level. Their most recent course used Minecraft to recreate historical places and events.

On gaming in (post-secondary) education:

This past year was the second time this professor used gaming in their course. The first time they had students theoretically create a game. One group actually created a working prototype which put users in the trenches of a World War I through the perspective of a medic. The professor ran into a lot of red tape when it came to trying new things. There was an entire procedure in place which required a business model to be drawn up, cost recovery, etc. Ultimately the hoops that needed to be jumped through were too big to tackle. The professor turned to the library to see if there was anything that could be done instead. Minecraft was a relatively cheap alternative that allowed students to interact in a way that this professor wanted.

On Minecraft resources:

The professor gave students free reign over the project. They were able to search the web for their own resources but the professor also created their own tutorial guide for the students to use and reference. User generated content is going to be a big focus of this paper. Henry Jenkins is a researcher who writes extensively about user generated content and participatory culture; I will be drawing on some aspects of Jenkins work toward the later part of my research paper.

On the value of Minecraft in teaching:

The professor wanted to engage with their students in a new way. They were not happy with the way essays were being used to grade student learning. Students write an essay, hand it in and receive their grade. This is a very closed method of learning. Students are writing essays and spending so much time researching only to have one person read the paper. By having students collaborate in an open world such as Minecraft they were creating and sharing content with their classmates. Instead of having the criteria given to them (for example a 4000 word paper on Ancient Greece) students really set the standard of how much they want to do with the project. This idea is discussed by psychologist Jacques Lacan who argues that the gaze is the anxious state that is reached knowing that you are being monitored (Felluga, 2011). The idea is that they are monitored by their peers and this idea of being monitored sets a higher standard for themselves. While sitting in the small coffee shop where I conducted the interview the professor drew a picture on their note pad. I have included the pictures below because I immediately thought their description was similar to Bates’ (1989) berrypicking theory. Although describing different things, interestingly enough they were similar in their foundations. The professor produced two sketches while we spoke. The first is an example where students are given a set of criteria that they use to complete an assignment. They do their work, research and submit their assignments within the criteria (or constraints) set out by the evaluator. There is very little if any peer input or collaboration.

Sketch of traditional essay criteria from interview with a professor 

The second sketch they drew was of the method they wanted to use in their classroom. The professor wanted the students to really control the criteria. The intent was that the gaze of the other students would shape the criteria for the assignment. The self monitoring of students would encourage the students to try new things and push the boundaries of the assignment. This is shown clearly in the diagram below.

Sketch of collaborative interactive monitoring form interview with a professor

I think this view the professor sets out for their students is one that very much resembles the berrypicking theory that Bates describes. It removes the rigorous boundaries of searching for information and creates a more natural approach. I have included a more thorough explanation of Bates’ berrypicking theory since I feel it ties in with the overall shift of attitude toward information seeking and towards learning in general. Bates (1989) argues that this model (made famous particularly by S.E. Robertson, which is shown below) has been the one in use in information sciences for over 25 years. However, with the advancement of information retrieval systems, Bates argues that there are increasing flaws in this model. She expands on this model by arguing that the search process is not as simple as the model below suggests and this model will actually limit us when developing new information retrieval systems.

Traditional query from Bates' The design of browsing and berrypicking techniques for the online search interface (1989)

Instead, Bates states searching occurs in a more fluid way. The image below shows how Bates believes information seeking behavior works. In her theory, the user conducts a query and receives information back. From there, the user absorbs and critically thinks about the material they received which then gives them new perspective on what they need from the information seeking process. The user conducts a new query, receives the information, critically examines it and conducts a new query continuing this process until completed.

Berrypicking theory from Bates' The design of browsing and berrypicking techniques for the online search interface (1989)

Observations on Minecraft as a teaching tool:

The professor spoke about some of the ideas students came up with after the project was completed. One of the students wrote a paper based on the gaming experience that tied in the idea of traditional gaming vs open world sandbox gaming to slavery throughout history. Another student tried to recreate the Halifax explosion using triggers within the world. When a user logged into the world a countdown to the ship’s explosion began, which wiped out the harbour. Another student took a different approach and used a famous painting as a backdrop for the recreation of their historical period. Not all projects were of the same caliber but even those where students admitted some failure, learning still occurred. This is one of the fundamental ideas that educational makerspaces are built upon. Failure within educational makerspaces must be tolerable. Big ideas are built upon the smaller failures that occur (Kurti, R., et al. 2014).

On the potential of gaming in (post-secondary) education:

The professor sees games as a new tool to write history. The tools need to be smart and not just centered around flashy graphics. They noted Assassin’s Creed as one example when graphics took precedence over historical accuracy.

References:

Bates, M. J. (1989). The design of browsing and berrypicking techniques for the online search interface. Online Review 13(5): 407-424.

Burnett, G. (2000). Information exchange in virtual communities: A typology. Information Research: An International Electronic Journal, 5, 82. doi: 10.1111/j.1083-6101.2004.tb00286.x

Felluga, Dino. (2011, January 31). Modules on Lacan. Retrieved from https://www.cla.purdue.edu/english/theory/psychoanalysis/lacangaze.html

Jenkins, H. (2009). Confronting the challenges of participatory culture: Media education for the 21st century. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.

Kurti, R. S., Kurti, D. L., & Fleming, L. (2014). The philosophy of educational makerspaces part 1 of making an educational makerspace. Teacher Librarian, 41(5), 8-11. Retrieved from http://www.proquest.com

Robertson, S. (1977). Theories and models in information-retrieval. Journal of documentation. 33(2), 126-148.

Savolainen, R. (2009). Everyday life information seeking. In Encyclopedia of Library and Information Sciences. doi: 10.1081/E-ELIS3-120043920

Sunday, February 8, 2015

My Research So Far

"Curiosity has the ability to reach deep into the soul and draw out the best and most engaging aspects of our personalities" (Kurti, R. Steven., et al., 2014).
I found this quote when working on my literature review and annotated bibliography for my LIBR 200 research paper. I never intended to be a teacher librarian but I feel like all librarians in some form or another are inherently teacher librarians in a sense. This quote was found when I was researching the learning potential that is emerging from educational makerspaces in libraries.
As can be seen from my previous blog post I will be studying Minecraft and its use as an educational tool and more interesting the information communities that are emerging as a result of the massive open world potential of creating in this virtual space.

One of the more interesting aspects of Minecraft and other educational makerspaces is the breakdown of terms like experts and professionals. In educational makerspaces the lines between teacher and student become increasingly blurred (Kurti, R. Steven., et al., 2014). When one user experiences a problem within an educational makerspace they openly collaborate with another user. In this situation one user becomes the student while the other takes on the classic role of the teacher. As the collaboration continues both users are actively engaged in the learning process.

Minecraft however is slightly different, unless the users computers are in the same room as each other Minecraft users cannot employ the same face-to-face collaboration as traditional makerspace users. This is where the creation of virtual web spaces like Project Minecraft and other information tools (such as YouTube) can shine. This is one aspect that I really want to focus on in my research paper. The role of user generated content (UGC) in Web 2.0 environments. YouTube in online information communities act an asynchronous collaborative tool amongst users. Feedback can be given in the form of comments. This kind of sharing of information can be seen in the video below.


In this video ACtennisAC (pseudonym) documents his problem solving thought process for creating an escalator in Minecraft. Using techniques used by other YouTube content creators they show various iterations of mechanisms that could create a working escalator in game. This virtual asynchronous collaboration allowed ACtennisAC to solve the problem he set out to solve and engage in the process of problem solving in a unique way.

In another video the same user documents his creative process in creating a 3D printer within Minecraft. I think that a lot of people will see these videos and ask, "Why would you need to create any of these things in a virtual world?" To them I would say this is the very essence of what Minecraft is, mini projects that encourage people to solve problems. These mini projects are giving users skills that can be applied to any project they will encounter in real life situations.

Also in my research I countered an interesting work by Henry Jenkins in Confronting the challenges of participatory culture: Media education for the 21st century that participatory culture will actually cause producers of UGC to better respect intellectual property rights of others since they will feel a greater state in the cultural economy (Jenkins, 2009). In another video by ACtennisAC he shares an interesting find which he credits another YouTube content creator for discovering something new in Minecraft. ACtennisAC is a great example of UGC and its importance in new technology.

So far, I feel like my research is going extremely well. I am discovering a lot of relevant literature that can be directly applied to Minecraft as an educational tool and how information communities are using information to share, collaborate and educate each other.

References:

Jenkins, H. (2009). Confronting the challenges of participatory culture: Media education for the 21st century. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.

Kurti, R. A., Kurti, D. A., & Fleming, L. L. (2014). The Philosophy of Educational Makerspaces. Teacher Librarian, 41(5), 8-11. Retrieved from www.ebscohost.com